Regional Baseball Stories – Baseball in Rugby

East Tennessee boasts a rich baseball heritage, celebrated through Regional Baseball Stories, a collection of submitted tales from the community.

Authored By Submitted on August 22, 2025
Submitted by G. Zepp

Rugby Tennessee opened in October 1880 with an early map of the village showing a cricket grounds. The Britishfounded village, composed of settlers from both England and elsewhere in America, initially attracted mostly young single men. By that time, the Civil War had boosted interest in baseball instead of that other bat-and-ball sport popular in Britain.

So it was little surprise that in Rugby baseball debuted on March 15, 1882. Youthful Britons as well as young Americans wanted the newest sport. And in Rugby, perhaps they were all tiring a bit of tennis.

The town newspaper advertised “A Base Ball Match” to be played at 2 p.m. between The Young America B.B.C. and The Pioneer B.B.C. The teams appeared from those titles to form along the lines of U.S. natives versus newly arrived settlers in the pioneering wilderness. This section of Tennessee was only opened to settlement with completion of the Cincinnati Southern’s railroad, also new in 1880.

Who won? Surprisingly, it was the Pioneers, “who with but one exception were Englishmen,” The Rugbeian reported.

“This, being the first time the Britishers had played the game, rather elated the Pioneers, and encouraged them in fresh efforts in their Cousins’ National field sport. The day was very fine, and we noticed on the ground the beauty, talent and elite of Rugby.”

The length of the game was 2 hours, 32 minutes. A.H. Brown served as the umpire while “Messrs. Marvin and
Alexander as scorers.”

Not content to play among themselves, Rugby lads very soon decided it was time for a town team. The very next month, a meeting at the schoolroom was called to former a proper club, bylaws and all.

By May 2, all governing rules were adopted and a site was chosen for play, with practice on May 13. But spring rain ruined an initial game that month.

By June 1882, the site picked near the “Savage Club” was described in the paper as “a very pretty break in the great
monotony of trees… which is used frequently for foot-ball, and base-ball games, and may be said to be the field of the Rugby Isthmian Games,” a reference to an ancient Greek festival. The town’s druggist, Thomas Fardon, was baseball club president.

On the Fourth of July in 1883, baseball was among the celebratory games of the holiday. “Lawn Tennis and Base-ball
were being played by some of the older inhabitants of the community and visitors to the town,” observed the Plateau-
Gazette as the newspaper was then called.

But the festivities for July 4 in 1885 were held on the grounds of Rugby’s first hotel, the Tabard Inn, which had burned to the ground the year before. That was a match between “the Rugby Base Ball Club and the Red Rovers,” who won 11-10.

It’s unclear where the Rovers were based, but in October of 1885 the Rugby team was scheduled to play Sunbright.
Something happened and the game had to be rescheduled for later that month in Sunbright, also in Morgan County.

Sunbright won, “mainly due to the close proximity of the creek to the playing ground, the ball being repeatedly lost in the brush on the creek bank,” the Rugby Gazette as it was then called reported. “Mr. Harry Blacklock filled the thankless office of umpire with judgement and fairness.”

Interest in the sport didn’t decline in the next decades in Rugby, even as its population did. Photographs in the Historic Rugby Archives today show several teams playing, with members recruited from nearby parts of Fentress County as well.

Team at Burrville, TN, 1911

More News

See All
From the Collection

Radio Roundup

The streetscape here at the Museum of East Tennessee History has undergone some changes and gained a few new additions to showcase. In particular, the three cases to the left of Trolly 416 are now inhabited by artifacts that give a glimpse into the rich history of radio in Tennessee.

From the Collection

A Closer Look at Trolley 416

Built in 1925 and once part of the city’s electric streetcar system, Car 416 carried passengers through downtown for over a decade before its retirement in the late 1930s. Unique features like upholstered seats, onboard mail slots, and its single-truck design made it both practical and ahead of its time. After decades as a vacation cabin, the car was rescued and restored, and now stands as a striking reminder of Knoxville’s streetcar era and the everyday lives it once connected.

ETHS News

Pete Claussen named “East Tennessean of the Year” for 2025

On Wednesday, November 12, 250 guests gathered to celebrate Pete Claussen, the 11th recipient of the East Tennessee Historical Society’s East Tennessean of the Year award at Cherokee Country Club in Knoxville. The annual event featured a cocktail hour with live music, a seated dinner, and an award presentation.